This exactly. Prior to the C20, the UK didn't have a left-wing party because the liberals and conservatives were both part of the aristocracy.
It's arguable that the US still lacks a left-wing party, and the presence of democratic socialists like Mamdini in the US Democrats is the exact parallel of socialists in the UK Liberal Party at the beginning of the twentieth century.
@ReggieHere @seb321 @jawarajabbi @benroyce
Well if that's the case, take note. If you spend a century being the left wing "working man's" party then start warmongering and leaning further right to try and prevent the fascists from voting for the nazis, you will fail and probably (hopefully) destroy yourselves.
@gareth @ReggieHere @seb321 @jawarajabbi
i see the welsh flag, i see the invective, time for this american to nope out, seeing as i ain't got no dog in this fight
I don't think it's a nationalist point. Labour under Blair reverted to liberalism and left-wingers across the UK were stranded without a party to vote for.
Scotland replaced Labour with the SNP and Wales is looking likely to do similar with Plaid at the next election. English left-wingers have mostly dropped Labour in favour of the Greens or YP.
@ReggieHere @gareth @seb321 @jawarajabbi
oh yeah, sorry. i mean i saw the welsh flag as in this is a british isles thing now, not as in this is a welsh independence thing now. and me in western new york i should keep my mouth shut
Would State independence movements be a way forward for progressives in the States?
@ReggieHere @gareth @seb321 @jawarajabbi
well had a wee little war over that
such moves are mostly championed by far right wackjobs. and funded by shady money that has the kremlin at its root
same with alberta in canada, with the added "bonus" that some of that money there is from USA MAGA
it's like brexit: it just makes putin smile and weakens his enemies, it's not a valid approach
Yes, democracy as a vehicle for regime change is an under-scrutinised political strategy.
That said, smaller national electorates in the UK have successfully ousted the mainstream Westminster parties....hence the question about the likes of New York State.
@ReggieHere @gareth @seb321 @jawarajabbi
well there's always this interplay between "states rights" and the feds
the right consistently whines about it
then they get in power and squash left leaning states rights
predictable hypocrisy
i can definitely see more assertion of the primacy of state govt over federal govt from the left if we don't improve
Interesting, The left-wing of the Democrats certainly seems to be gaining momentum.
